Child Custody, New York Family Law Group

What Can Be Used Against You in a Custody Battle in New York?

Last updated on September 18, 2023

Child custody battles can be emotionally charged and highly contentious affairs, often leaving parents feeling overwhelmed and uncertain about their rights. In the state of New York, where custody decisions are made based on the best interests of the child, parents must understand what factors can potentially be used against them in these legal disputes. Whether you are seeking sole custody, joint custody, or visitation rights, being aware of the elements that may impact the court’s decision is essential. 

Navigating the intricacies of a custody battle in New York can be a daunting task, but having a knowledgeable and experienced child custody lawyer by your side can make a significant difference. A Manhattan child custody lawyer can provide valuable guidance and support in understanding the advantages and disadvantages of joint custody. They have an in-depth understanding of the state’s laws, court procedures, and precedents, allowing them to effectively evaluate your case and develop a robust strategy tailored to your specific circumstances. At New York Family Law Group, our skilled New York child custody attorneys may be able to help protect your rights, gather evidence, negotiate with the opposing party, and present a compelling argument in court. By working with our team, you can increase your chances of securing a favorable outcome and ensuring the best interests of your child are prioritized. Call us today at (347) 212-5113 to schedule a consultation.

Understanding Custody Battles in New York

Custody battles are legal disputes between parents who are going through a divorce or separation. In these cases, the court decides which parent has the right to make decisions about the child’s upbringing and where the child will live. In New York, child custody issues are a complex area of the law. This article aims to provide an overview of custody battles in New York, including the types of custody that may be awarded, criteria for determining custody, and common factors judges consider.

Types of Child Custody in New York

There are two main types of custody in New York: legal custody and physical custody. Legal custody refers to the right and responsibility to make decisions about a child’s well-being, including matters related to education, religion, and medical care. Physical custody, on the other hand, refers to where a child lives and who is responsible for meeting the child’s day-to-day needs.

Legal custody can be further divided into two categories: sole legal custody and joint legal custody. If a parent has sole legal custody, they have the exclusive right to make decisions about their child’s well-being. Joint legal custody, on the other hand, means that both parents have an equal right to make decisions for their children. This latter category often requires both parents to communicate and cooperate in order to reach a consensus in decision-making.

Similarly, physical custody can be divided into two categories: sole physical custody and joint physical custody. In cases where one parent is awarded sole physical custody, the child will primarily live with that parent, and the other parent may be granted visitation rights. Joint physical custody, sometimes referred to as shared custody, allows for the child to spend significant time living with both parents, often on a set schedule.

Visitation rights are the time the non-custodial parent spends with the child. Visitation can be supervised or unsupervised, depending on the circumstances. Supervised visitation may be necessary in cases where there are concerns for the child’s safety or well-being when in the care of the non-custodial parent.

Criteria for Determining Child Custody

In New York, the main criterion for determining child custody is the “best interests of the child” standard. This principle is followed by the courts to ensure that custody arrangements promote the child’s overall well-being, including their physical, emotional, and mental health. These factors can include:

  • Co-Parenting Abilities: Even in cases of separated living arrangements, parents are expected to demonstrate effective co-parenting abilities. It is natural for co-parents to occasionally encounter minor disagreements, as even married parents may not always see eye to eye on parenting decisions. However, the court must have confidence that both parents can navigate these disagreements and find compromises that lead to mutually agreeable resolutions. If one parent consistently undermines the other and prioritizes their personal agenda over the best interests of the child, it may raise concerns for the court.
  • Emotional and Physical Capacity: The court will also evaluate whether both parents possess the emotional and physical capacity to adequately care for the child. For instance, a parent struggling with substance abuse is unlikely to provide the necessary stability and care required by the child.
  • Importance of Consistency: Consistency plays a vital role in ensuring children feel secure in their lives. Knowing their parent’s daily work schedule, meal times, bedtime routine, and having a predictable routine all contribute to a child’s well-being. If a parent is unwilling or unable to adjust their lifestyle to accommodate these needs, the court will take this into consideration, which could potentially reduce their chances of obtaining custody.
  • Past Incidents of Domestic Violence: If a parent has a history of domestic violence towards the other parent or the child, it is highly improbable that they will be granted custody. In such cases, the court often restricts visitation rights and may even require supervised visitation, depending on the severity of the violence.

Custody battles in New York can be both emotionally and financially draining. It is important to consult an experienced family law attorney who can provide guidance, support, and representation throughout the process. The ultimate goal in a child custody case is to ensure the best possible outcome for the child, and understanding New York’s custody laws can help parents prepare for these critical legal proceedings.

Manhattan child custody attorney

Factors that Can Be Used Against You in a Custody Battle

Some factors that the courts will consider when deciding on the matter of child custody include but are not limited to the following:

Prior Criminal History

Having a prior criminal history refers to any previous convictions or encounters with the law that resulted in criminal charges. It encompasses a wide range of offenses, including but not limited to theft, assault, drug-related crimes, fraud, and driving under the influence (DUI). During a custody battle, the existence of a criminal record can be used against you, as it raises significant concerns about your ability to provide a safe and stable environment for your child. 

The court may question whether your past behavior indicates a potential risk to the child’s well-being or poses a threat to their safety. Factors such as the severity and recency of the criminal history, as well as any efforts made towards rehabilitation and personal growth, will also be taken into consideration by the court.

History of Abuse or Neglect

A history of abuse or neglect refers to instances where you have been involved in mistreating or failing to meet the needs of your child. This can encompass various forms of harm, including physical, emotional, or sexual abuse, as well as neglecting the child’s basic needs, such as proper nutrition, hygiene, medical care, and education. 

When determining child custody, courts prioritize the safety, well-being, and best interests of the child. Therefore, evidence of abuse or neglect can significantly impact your custody case and may even result in limited or supervised visitation, or a complete loss of custody rights. It is crucial to address these issues head-on, take responsibility for past actions, and demonstrate genuine remorse and a commitment to change. 

This can involve participating in therapy, attending parenting classes, and engaging in rehabilitation programs to address any underlying issues contributing to the abusive or neglectful behavior. Providing evidence of positive changes and ongoing efforts toward personal growth and improved parenting skills will be essential in persuading the court that you can now provide a loving, nurturing, and safe environment for your child.

Issues with Substance Abuse

Issues with substance abuse pertain to problems associated with drug or alcohol addiction. If you have a history of substance abuse, it raises concerns about your ability to create and maintain a stable, healthy, and safe environment for your child. Substance abuse can impair judgment, affect emotional stability, and compromise your capacity to fulfill parental responsibilities effectively. 

When determining custody, the court will prioritize the child’s best interests which includes ensuring their physical and emotional well-being. To strengthen your case, it is vital to demonstrate that you are committed to sobriety and have taken tangible steps toward recovery. This may involve completing a rehabilitation program, attending support group meetings, undergoing regular drug tests to establish ongoing sobriety, and engaging in therapy to address the underlying causes of addiction. 

Additionally, providing a well-structured and supportive post-recovery plan, such as having a stable living environment, reliable employment, and a strong support network, can help assure the court that you are equipped to provide a stable and secure environment for your child.

Parental Alienation

Parental alienation occurs when one parent actively seeks to manipulate the child’s emotions and undermine their relationship with the other parent. This behavior can involve making derogatory remarks about the other parent, restricting access or communication, or attempting to turn the child against the other parent through subtle or overt means. Accusations of parental alienation can significantly impact your custody case, as it suggests a lack of willingness to foster a cooperative co-parenting relationship and may raise concerns about your ability to prioritize the child’s best interests. 

To counter such accusations, it is crucial to provide evidence that you actively support and encourage the child’s relationship with the other parent. This can include documentation of positive and consistent communication, records of facilitating visitation and shared parenting time, and testimonies from witnesses who can affirm your commitment to nurturing a healthy parent-child relationship. It is important to maintain a cooperative and child-centered approach throughout the custody proceedings, demonstrating your willingness to collaborate with the other parent for the well-being of your child. 

Frequent Relocations

Frequent relocations refer to a pattern of frequently changing residences or moving from one place to another within a short span of time. In custody cases, courts emphasize the importance of stability and consistency in a child’s life. Frequent moves can disrupt a child’s sense of stability, impacting their education, social connections, and overall well-being. It may raise concerns about your ability to provide a reliable and consistent home environment. 

To address this issue, it is essential to demonstrate to the court that you are committed to establishing stability in your child’s life. This can be achieved by providing evidence of a long-term residence, such as a lease agreement or mortgage statement, enrolling the child in a consistent school or extracurricular activities, and presenting a feasible and sustainable plan for stable housing in the future. 

Additionally, showcasing a strong support network in the current location, including family, friends, or community connections, can further demonstrate your ability to create a stable and nurturing environment for your child.

Inability to Co-parent Effectively

The ability to co-parent effectively refers to your capacity to communicate, cooperate, and make joint decisions with the child’s other parent in matters related to the child’s well-being. If you have a history of not being able to work collaboratively with the other parent, it can adversely impact your custody case. Courts value parents who prioritize the child’s best interests and demonstrate a willingness to cooperate for the sake of the child’s emotional and psychological development. 

To strengthen your position, it is crucial to show the court that you are capable of setting aside personal conflicts and working together with the other parent. This can involve engaging in constructive and respectful communication, attending co-parenting classes or therapy sessions to improve conflict resolution skills, and providing examples of successful co-parenting efforts in the past. Demonstrating a willingness to be flexible, considerate, and respectful towards the other parent’s rights and responsibilities can help establish your ability to contribute to a healthy and supportive co-parenting relationship.

Financial Instability

While financial stability is not the sole determinant in custody cases, a parent’s financial situation can impact their ability to meet the child’s material needs and provide a secure and comfortable environment. Financial instability can raise concerns about your ability to provide for the child’s basic necessities, such as food, clothing, housing, education, and healthcare. To address this concern, it is crucial to have a well-thought-out plan that demonstrates your commitment to fulfilling the child’s financial needs. 

This can include providing evidence of stable employment or income sources, a budget plan that accounts for the child’s expenses, and a willingness to seek additional employment or opportunities for financial growth. Additionally, presenting a support system, such as family members or community resources, that can offer assistance in times of financial strain can further strengthen your case. It is essential to reassure the court that despite any previous financial challenges, you have a solid plan in place to provide for the child’s well-being and are actively taking steps to improve your financial stability.

Mental Health Issues

Mental health issues can also be a factor considered in custody cases, as they can potentially affect a parent’s ability to provide consistent and effective care for the child. The court will examine whether your mental health condition impacts your capacity to fulfill your parental responsibilities and maintain a safe and nurturing environment for your child. It is important to note that having a mental health issue does not automatically disqualify you from custody, but it does require careful consideration and evidence of your ability to manage your condition and provide for your child’s needs.

In addition to treatment, it is essential to showcase any progress or improvements you have made in managing your mental health condition. This can be done through testimonials from mental health professionals who can attest to your stability, participation in support groups or community organizations related to your mental health condition, and evidence of positive coping mechanisms or strategies you have developed.

Negative Testimonies from Witnesses

Testimonies from witnesses that portray you in a negative light can have a significant impact on your custody case. These witnesses may include family members, friends, neighbors, or professionals who have observed your parenting skills or interactions with the child. Negative testimonies can potentially raise concerns about your ability to provide a safe and nurturing environment.

To counter negative testimonies, it is crucial to challenge their credibility and present contradicting evidence or alternative perspectives. This can involve presenting witnesses of your own who can provide positive and supportive accounts of your parenting abilities and offering tangible evidence that refutes the claims made against you. This evidence can include documentation of your involvement in the child’s life, such as records of school or medical appointments, communication logs with the other parent, and character references from individuals who can vouch for your parenting skills.

Remember, each custody case is unique, and the weight given to these factors may vary depending on the specific circumstances and the family court’s jurisdiction. It is crucial to consult with a family law attorney who can provide tailored guidance based on the laws and regulations applicable to your situation.

Factors That Can Be Used Against You in a Custody Battle Impact on Custody Case
Prior Criminal History Raises concerns about providing a safe and stable environment for the child
History of Abuse or Neglect Can result in limited or supervised visitation, or a complete loss of custody rights
Issues with Substance Abuse Raises concerns about creating and maintaining a stable, healthy, and safe environment
Parental Alienation Suggests a lack of willingness to foster a cooperative co-parenting relationship
Frequent Relocations Raises concerns about stability and consistency in the child’s life
Inability to Co-parent Adversely impacts custody case
Financial Instability Raises concerns about meeting the child’s material needs and providing a secure and comfortable environment
Mental Health Issues Requires careful consideration and evidence of ability to manage the condition and provide for the child’s needs
Negative Testimonies Can raise concerns about providing a safe and nurturing environment

Legal Representation and Support in Custody Battles

The custody battle process in New York can be a highly challenging and emotional experience, as it involves intricate legal procedures and various factors that can potentially be used against you. Understanding what can be used against you is crucial for parents involved in a custody dispute, as it allows them to prepare and present their case effectively.

Throughout the custody battle, several key factors can significantly impact the court’s decision. These include a parent’s history of substance abuse, domestic violence, neglect, or any actions that demonstrate a lack of ability to provide a safe and stable environment for the child. Additionally, the court considers each parent’s ability to meet the child’s physical, emotional, and educational needs, as well as their willingness to foster a positive relationship between the child and the other parent.

A Manhattan child custody lawyer can help you understand your rights, gather evidence, and develop a strong legal strategy to present your case in the most favorable light. At New York Family Law Group, our team of Manhattan child custody attorneys may be able to guide you in negotiations and mediation, striving to reach an agreement that serves the best interests of your child while protecting your parental rights. Contact us today at (347) 212-5113 to learn more about how we can help.



More Resources